top of page

Response to the article: ‘Rehabilitation is not the enemy: Reframing Long Covid and ME/CFS care’ by Manoj Sivan, Russell Fleming and Danny M Altmann

2 hours ago
7 min read
By Dr Elke Hausmann



We have a special article from a good friend of Long Covid Advocacy, Dr Elke Hausmann. Dr Hausmann is a former GP who had to stop working due to Long Covid and therefore brings a personal and professional perspective to this article on the nature of rehabilitation. She has published in BJGP Life and written for us about Mendenhall and Levinovitz. You can find her on Bluesky @drelke.bsky.social



In their article, the three authors set out their vision for Long Covid and ME/CFS care framed through the rehabilitation approach. You have to read it a couple of times – at first glance, it presents many of the issues in ways that patients would agree with: the fact that neither condition is psychosomatic, that we have already learned a lot about the underlying disease processes and are continuing to learn more all the time, acknowledging the existence of post-exertional malaise or PEM (though unfortunately equating it with post-exertional symptom exacerbation or PESE), etc.


However, on repeat reading, it becomes clear that the authors are setting up a straw man that they can argue against: patients who reject the rehab approach because they do not understand that rehab is about more than physical rehabilitation or exercise, and who are expecting the impossible: medical, particularly curative, treatment which simply does not exist yet. By using the term ‘enemy’, they are also straying dangerously close to discourses that set up patients against doctors (or health care professionals in general) as ‘enemies’.


That strawman argument basically allows them to state that rehabilitation is everything that does exist: medical treatment we already have that can reduce certain aspects of the impact of disease (without reversing the pathology), therapies that address the illness experience of the patient, as well as supportive care.


What this means is that they can neatly sidestep the real problem that patients who criticise the rehab approach have with it, which concerns the elephant in the room that is mentioned, but is not put front and centre of their approach: PEM.


By definition, people with ME have PEM, and a large proportion of patients with Long Covid, many of whom are significantly restricted in their function, also have PEM. What they forget is that PEM changes everything (and by the way, ‘avoidance of symptom crashes’ can certainly be a goal, but can it really be achieved? We know from experience that crashes can happen, no matter how well you manage your illness).


We have no medical treatment yet that addresses PEM, and many of us who have gone through the rehab approach have found that neither do we know of any therapies that can improve function if you have PEM.


The value of the rehab approach here is equated to what rehab can do in a complementary fashion in other conditions, without clearly stating that there is a difference in helping people regain function after they have had surgery on their knee arthritis or had their stroke treated by medical intervention: in both cases the primary pathology was treated to the point where the body was ready to improve, supported by strategies that we know through RCTs do work.


In the article, the authors repeatedly state that the rehab approach offers therapies that can improve function, this is not posed as a question, it is confidently stated. Yes, therapies may help some patients with some aspects of function, especially if they don’t have PEM, but if they do have PEM, that is usually very limited to non-existent.


If we had therapies that could really improve function in people with PEM, then we would not have the problem of severe and very severe ME (characterised by extreme PEM). The authors talk about subgroups, and we do have some medical treatments to address some of them, but access to those is pretty aspirational at present. Access to doctors and medical treatment is a core demand of patients, who want Long Covid and ME care be centred around that, rather than therapies.

Dobbin has been shocked by almost non-existent NHS services. She was referred to an NHS clinic for Long Covid, where there were “loads of lovely people”, including physios and therapists, who offered tips such as meditation and sleep hygiene.”But there were no doctors. The Times

Then we are left with support. Patients value it when they get support from the healthcare and therapy staff they are seeing in clinics. They want more of it. The problem is that we are heading into political territory now: while support is invaluable to patients, it is harder to argue that it is cost-effective if it can’t be shown to consistently reinstate function (eg the ability to work for those who can’t).


The issues that patients have with the rehab approach can be summarised as follows, in terms of what we’d like to see:


1. Specialist care for Long Covid and ME patients needs to be first and foremost about access to doctors and medical treatments (including and especially for those who are most severe and cannot attend a clinic). Doctors can only build up their expertise through the experience of seeing people with these conditions regularly.


2. Patients value support, in terms of validating their illness experience, adapting to living with a chronic illness, practical support (eg with work adjustments or benefits applications), and psychological support if necessary. Above all, they want a service that is adequate for their needs that continues to support them, and does not discharge them when it is judged that no (further) functional improvements can be achieved.


3. We need services to acknowledge that we do not know how to improve function through therapies in the presence of PEM. Some people might get some benefit in terms of function, if they come to a clinic knowing absolutely nothing about how to manage their condition, but as the authors correctly state, patients often already know about pacing when they reach a clinic, and may already live within their energy envelope (the might have seen a bit of a functional improvement after introducing pacing), so there is a limit to how much more functional improvement can be achieved.  

 

There is a problem with applying a goal-setting approach in the context of PEM if that assumes that consistent efforts can lead to a linear recovery. That’s how the concept of pacing can all too easily morph into ‘pacing up’, seen as preferable to GET (graded exercise therapy) in the context of physical rehabilitation and exercise, because it is ‘patient led’ rather than relying on fixed incremental increases in activities (this can of course be applied to any activities, including activities of daily living): it may be accepted that patients might not be able to increase their activities within a certain timescale or at all, but the central aim is still to increase activity (which is often equated with increasing function) – this can lead to feelings of guilt on part of the patients who are not able to do that, and of course lead to setbacks if patients are pushing themselves too much to reach any particular goals. Not only does this approach not work, it is counterproductive and harmful.


There are some really good points in this article, but it is let down by its framing – it sets out the straw man of a patient group critical of the rehabilitation approach only because they falsely equate it with physical rehabilitation or exercise, PEM is not put front and centre, and when they say ‘rehabilitation should not be contingent on a future mechanistic breakthrough’, that misses completely the concerns that patients have about the rehab approach, which centres around the question of how much any therapies can actually achieve in terms of improving people’s function in the absence of a disease-modifying treatment or even a cure.


We need to be honest about what can be achieved with the knowledge we have today – educating patients about their condition can help to stabilise them (at which point some of them, especially in the absence of PEM, might improve, and yes, maybe even return to work or study, but others will not), it can help prevent patients from deteriorating, but how much can it actively make them better?


As a final point, it is crucial that services for Long Covid and ME keep in mind those with the greatest need, which are the patients who are severe and very severe. If we had more doctors who learn about managing Long Covid and ME through working with patients with those conditions in clinics up and down the country, if they would see their most ill patients (who cannot come to clinic) in their homes, then such patients might not have to go into hospital as an emergency when that could be avoided with treatment at home, and if they ever reached hospital, the hospital doctors could fall back on their expertise in how to manage such medically challenging patients to avoid further tragedies where patients die because they are not offered life-saving treatments, eg nutritional support through enteral or parenteral feeding.


It’s worth considering the key findings and recommendations with regards to ‘healthcare services for ME/CFS, Post-Covid Syndrome, POTS and environmental illness’ by the working group appointed by the Director of Health in Iceland from September 2026. Among other points, it states: ‘It is proposed that ME should be defined as a serious chronic neurological disease, for which conventional rehabilitation is not indicated’.


Whether or not you agree with that exact characterisation of ME, any Long Covid and ME/CFS care service, even if it proposes to cater for a wide range of patients (with and without PEM), and with a wide range of needs, first has to take that point on rehabilitation on board.



Full disclosure, since the summer I have been a member of the HERITAGE study’s PAG (Patient Advisory Group) and attended some meetings, both with the PAG and with the wider HERITAGE team. We all want Long Covid and ME/CFS care in this country to get better, but we can only get there if we are all on the same page.


Comments


bottom of page