Our comment on ‘Rehabilitation is not the enemy: Reframing Long Covid and ME/CFS care’ by Sivan, Fleming & Altmann.
LCA position statement
We have placed our thread on Twitter and Bluesky (20/11/26) here for easy access.
TLDR: The question of whether rehab is appropriate at all needs to fundamentally questioned. Rehab tailored to PEM, & ME not seen as psychosomatic:
Post-rehabilitation Bell Disability Scale scores decreased in 42/94 (45%) Peters et al. (2026)
We agree that everyone wants decent Long Covid and ME care. The serious issue we have with this abstact is its negation of how profoundly patients engaging with integrated MDT clinics have struggled to access quality care. It is no secret that a vast swath of this patient population have shared horror story after horror story of appointments within the past and current MDT system, and that many do not even have access to medical care.
It is nothing short of a medical scandal.
We question whether the response or solution to this is that patients misunderstand the definition of rehab. We would argue this isn’t a patient comprehension issue nor the blame to be placed on patients. It is a cultural & education problem within medicine. We have seen time and again that whilst the model is not bluntly psychosomatic (no one frames care like this), it is clearly based on a biopsychosocial model, often within the framework of long term conditions & medically unexplained symptoms (MUS).
Until those involved can see that it is the biopsychosocial model endorsed by these clinics that is the key cause of so much medical neglect, abandonedment & gaslighting & can separate from it there will continue to be issues, regardless of intent.
The BPS model allows an attitude and cultural framing of psychologisation into the clinical system. We have seen this through slides presented at the Long Covid Conference, that ME clinics that do not all align with NICE guidelines, and the mountain of patient testimony.
It is clear that an independent assessment of the clinical system needs to be conducted by those without career and personal involvement. A system cannot be assessed by those who are invested in it. Patients also need a reporting system external to those responsible for their care, with a wide remit to suggest alternatives.
We don't need tweeking or tailoring we need reform from the bottom up.
It is our view that this abstract demonstrates a profound lack of understanding and acts more as a position statement that places blame on patients, which the MDT system so often does. It is our stance that radical reform & thinking is needed and that a medicalised system of consultants and specialist nurses is needed, (with appropriate education) who can then refer to rehabilitation specialists if required.
Rehab here is presented in such a broad definition that anything can be inferred, our concern is that it is positioning itself to be the long-term specialty that people with Long Covid and ME should be under. We are not arguing that there is no place for rehabilitation. But that it shouldn't have central positioning as those involved do not often have the medical training & expertise to deal with severe cases. We need more than breathing exercises, activity & goal setting.
This positioning of rehab as central is problematic, especially as the paper is unable to acknowledge, engage with or apologise for the medical harms the rehabilitation-led system has been complicit in.
We believe that those most severely affected should be prioritised in healthcare & included and this is not happening. It is vital that the NHS commission services for people with severe and very severe Long Covid and ME.
The state of the clinical system is worthy of inclusion in a parliamentary Select Committee Inquiry into the historical and ongoing failures of ME healthcare. The scandal of ME is it's impact on Long Covid clinics is not separate from clinical healthcare - it is the scandal. We also believe there should be consideration of a statutory public inquiry into these failures, including the experiences of patients harmed by existing and previous models of care.
To really change the clinics we need profound reform in the education & research system. Without dealing with the fundamental cultural issues we will be failed by the systemic bias of a medical system that has no roots to build a clinical system on.
Our concern is that millions are being spent, LOCOMOTION £3.4 mil ( gold standard LC clinical care) HERITAGE £1.4 mill (evaluate clinics & inform services) to create a clinical system that still fails patients. For decent clinics we need millions dedicated to parhology & education.
Full abstract by Sivan, Fleming, Altmann:




Comments